THE PREMIERE WEBSITE FOR POLICE NEWS IN TEXAS
SOUND-OFF
LINKS/ EVENTS/ BOOKS/ JOBS/ ARCHIVES & COMMENTS/ TWITTER/ THE BLUE PAGES / BACK ISSUES / WEATHER
ABOUT THE POLICE NEWS /
FACEBOOK / PHOTOS & VIDEOS / Texas Most Wanted
 

HOME PAGE

 

ABOUT US

 SUBSCRIBE HERE
 BUSINESS DIRECTORY
 

AMBER ALERTS

 

EVENTS CALENDAR

 

CONTACT US

 CLASSIFIED ADS
 

EMPLOYMENT

 NATIONAL NIGHT OUT 2013
 

OP/EDs

 SUBSCRIBER CITIES
 

HELPFUL LINKS

 TEXAS MOST WANTED
 

PHOTO GALLERY

 

RECORDED 
INTERVIEWS

 

ARCHIVES

 

P-2-C

 

RECOMMENDED
READING

 

SOUND-OFF

 

YOUR WEATHER

 

Mom of Murdered Boy Freed From Death Row
Detective with an alarming history of misconduct
   
 
More Today's News:
  A determined Linda Tweedie going through therapy, hoping to walk to May 30 fundraiser
  “Chief’s Corner”
  Galveston - Body found near Galveston Seawall
  Galveston - Woman kidnapped, sexually assaulted
  Baytown - Man charged with murder in death of girlfriend's baby
  Dallas - Field Sobriety Training To Resume at Police Academy
  Dallas - Marijuana Distribution Conspiracy iGets Man 17 Years in Federal Prison
  Dallas - Police shoot armed man after half hour chase
  Damon - Brazoria County Fire Chief killed battling fire
  Fort Bend County - Judge hands down probation for Deadly Conduct conviction
  Friendswood - Police Activity Report
  Friendswood - Woman charged in Galveston DUI death arrested again
  Galveston - Houston bicyclist hit by car on San Luis Pass Road
  Galveston - Mayoral Candidate Forums
  Houston - Fatal Traffic Accident
  Houston - Homicide investigating fatal shooting
  Houston - Six Teens, Ages 14-18, Arrested For Burglarizing Home
  Houston - Woman claims she was beaten during arrest
  Hurst - Weekly Crime Information
  LaPorte - Another Rape Aggression Defense course offered by LaPorte PD
  Lewisville - Police Chief's Weekly Update
  Midlothian - Officer hurt in crash succumbs to injuries
  MOST WANTED - Galveston County Sheriff
  MOST WANTED - Harris County Sheriff
  MOST WANTED - Texas City Police
  Nacogdoches - 3 jailed in drug arrests
  Orange - Woman killed in motorcycle accident, daughter injured
  Pet Abuse Case Updates
  Plano - Traffic crash with serious injuries
  Port Bolivar - Investigators hope discovery of murder victim’s vehicle will provide new clues
  Salt Lake City - Defendant Killed by Court Officer in Courtroom
  San Marcos - Armed robbery crime of the week
  Texas - Use Online Driver License Services
  Texas City -Police offering reward if you can help them find missing statue
  Wash. D.C. - EquuSearch sues feds to use drones in searches
  La Marque - City employee charges with theft
  Albuquerque - Police officer fatally shoots car thief
  Boston - Family remembers police officer killed days after bombings
  Brownsville - Judge allows mother of boy shot by police to join suit
  BUSTED & CUFFED - Some that didn't get away

   Next >>
Search Archives:
March 17, 2013

By JAMIE ROSS
- A woman should not have been convicted of murdering her 4-year-old son based solely on the testimony of a detective with an alarming history of misconduct, the 9th Circuit ruled.

     Debra Milke was 25 and newly divorced in December 1989 when her son Christopher asked to see Santa Claus at the mall for the second time in as many days.

     Milke's roommate James Styers agreed to take the boy but made a detour to pick up his friend Roger Scott. They then took 4-year-old Christopher to a secluded ravine where they shot him three times in the head. The men proceeded to the mall in Phoenix, Ariz., and reported Christopher as missing, but police suspected foul play.

     Scott quickly confessed and implicated Debra Milke in the plot. Phoenix Police Detective Armando Saldate brought the mother in, told her that her son was dead and then arrested her.

     By his version of events, Milke immediately confessed to a murder conspiracy. He said she had also spoke about nearly aborting Christopher when she became pregnant, and that lately she had worried that he was becoming like his father. Saldate did not record the interrogation, however, and he also failed to have Milke sign a waiver of her Miranda rights and or have other officers witness the interrogation.

     Apart from Saldate's memory, Milke has consistently denied involvement in the murder. She gives a substantially account of the interrogation and says Saldate ignored her requests for a lawyer.

     Though there was no physical evidence linking Milke to the murder, and neither Scott nor Styers would testify against her, the jury credited Saldate's word and convicted Milke of murder, conspiracy to commit murder, child abuse and kidnapping.
     Styers and Scott meanwhile were both convicted separately in the murder.

     One of three women on Arizona's death row, Milke failed to win a writ of habeas corpus from a federal judge, but a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit reversed Thursday.

     The 60-page decision, complete with an appendix of Saldate's misconduct and a concurrence by Chief Judge Alex Kozinski, notes that the "state remained unconstitutionally silent instead of disclosing information about Det. Saldate's history of misconduct and accompanying court orders and disciplinary action."

     Saldate's record includes a five-day suspension for "taking liberties" with a female motorist and lying about it to his superiors, according to the ruling. He was also involved in eight cases that judges had to overthrow or dismiss because he lied under oath or violated the Fourth or Fifth Amendment rights of detainees.

     Kozinski, who also wrote the lead opinion, said in the concurrence that Milke's case is "disturbing."
     After noting that Saldate's testimony has no corroboration from Milke's alleged co-conspirators, Kozinski called Saldate's interrogation methods "equally troubling."

     "Saldate's supervisor asked him to record Milke's interrogation, yet Saldate didn't even take a tape recorder with him," Kozinski wrote. "Saldate claims that Milke refused to have the conversation recorded, but admits that he 'basically didn't want to record it anyway.' And why not? Because 'a tape recorder is an obstacle for [him] to get to the truth' and so 'it's [his] practice never to use a tape recorder.' Of course, being left with no recording is an obstacle for us to get to the truth, but Saldate tells us not to worry: '[The] conversation was going to be noted by me in a truthful manner, so there was really no need for tape recording.' Right."

     In addition to an absent Miranda waiver, Saldate also destroyed his notes from the interrogation, "leaving us no objectively verifiable proof as to what happened inside," the ruling states.

     "Milke may well be guilty, even if Saldate made up her confession out of whole cloth," Kozinski added. "After all, it's hard to understand what reason Styers and Scott would have had for killing a four-year-old boy. Then again, what reason would they have to protect her if they know she's guilty? But I seriously doubt the jury would have convicted Milke without the purported confession."

     Arizona must turn over Saldate's police personnel records to Milke's lawyers, and the District Court must release Milke unless the state notifies the court within 30 days that it plans to retry her, according to the ruling.

 

 


 

 

 

 

 


 



Comments:

Typical thin blue line roaches like Saldate will never see a jail cell, cops have there own justice will do anything to get a result with the US system of elected DA's it perjures the ideals of habeas corpus.

Hope the puke gets impregnated by bubba!

Posted by scott at 9/12/2013 1:55:15 AM

Post a comment

Name/Nickname:
(required)

Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)

Comments: (plain text only)

Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
  Share   Share link on Twitter Tweet  

© 1999-2014 The Police News. All rights reserved.