THE PREMIERE WEBSITE FOR POLICE NEWS IN TEXAS
SOUND-OFF
LINKS/ EVENTS/ BOOKS/ JOBS/ ARCHIVES & COMMENTS/ TWITTER/ THE BLUE PAGES / BACK ISSUES / WEATHER
ABOUT THE POLICE NEWS /
FACEBOOK / PHOTOS & VIDEOS / Texas Most Wanted
 

HOME PAGE

 

ABOUT US

 SUBSCRIBE HERE
 BUSINESS DIRECTORY
 

AMBER ALERTS

 

EVENTS CALENDAR

 

CONTACT US

 CLASSIFIED ADS
 

EMPLOYMENT

 NATIONAL NIGHT OUT 2013
 

OP/EDs

 SUBSCRIBER CITIES
 

HELPFUL LINKS

 TEXAS MOST WANTED
 

PHOTO GALLERY

 

RECORDED 
INTERVIEWS

 

ARCHIVES

 

P-2-C

 

RECOMMENDED
READING

 

SOUND-OFF

 

YOUR WEATHER

 

Texas AG Unveils Constitutional Defects with Federal Public Safety Employees Act
The Police News
   
 
More Today's News:
  “Chief’s Corner”
  A determined Linda Tweedie going through therapy, hoping to walk to May 30 fundraiser
  Amber Alert
  Bryan - Woman Heads to Prison in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy
  Conroe - Police seize 80 lbs Marijuana
  Employment - Dickinson Police Dept - Full-time Communications Operator
  Employment - Police Officer - City of Santa Fe
  Employment - Police Officer - City of Webster
  Fort Bend County - Deputies seek church parking lot car burglars
  Fort Worth - TCU football player arrested
  Galveston County sheriff’s deputy sues after being struck by drunk driver
  Georgetown - Officer on leave after video shows him tripping students
  Have You Seen This Child?
  Houston - Investigation into Fatal Traffic Accident
  Houston - Family affected by HPD homicide probe speaks out
  Houston - Police Officer Union Announce Endorsements
  Houston - Suspect Arrested, Charged in Deaths of Two Men
  La Marque - High School student arrested for having loaded gun on campus
  La Marque Police Endorse Bethea For City Council
  League City - Council considers tough restrictions on pit bulls after toddler mauling
  MOST WANTED - Galveston County Sheriff
  MOST WANTED - Harris County Sheriff
  MOST WANTED - Texas City Police
  Nacogdoches - County Deputies were involved in a shooting
  Plano - Fatal traffic crash
  San Antonio - ICE deports a previously deported Guatemalan wanted for rape
  San Antonio - Police have released the identity of the person shot to death by officers
  Time for Texas to rein in ‘lawsuit lending’
  Albuquerque - Police fatally shoot 19-year-old woman
  Dallas - Homicide detectives working 2 deaths overnight
  DOJ announces clemency overhaul, allows release for some after 10 years
  Galveston - Body found near Galveston Seawall
  Galveston - Woman kidnapped, sexually assaulted
  Harris County - Former detention officer charged with delivering contraband
  Jefferson County - Deputies make 3 arrests in murder case
  Lewisville - P olice are seeking the public’s help in finding armed robber
  Open animal cruelty cases
  Texas City - Three jailed in drug bust
  Baytown - Man charged with murder in death of girlfriend's baby
  Dallas - Field Sobriety Training To Resume at Police Academy

   Next >>
Search Archives:

July 12, 2010

AUSTIN - Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott today identified multiple constitutional defects with the so-called Public Safety Employer-Employee Cooperation Act, a bill pending before the U.S. Senate that would coerce state and local governments to collectively bargain with labor unions representing certain public employees.

In a letter to U.S. Senator John Cornyn (Texas), Attorney General Abbott explained that the Act violates both the Tenth Amendment and the Eleventh Amendment, and exceeds Congress' authority to regulate interstate commerce.

"The federal government is attempting to intrude upon our state's authority to independently manage relations with our public employees," Attorney General Abbott said. "This law would force the State of Texas into federally mandated collective bargaining agreements with labor unions - despite the fact that state law does not authorize collective bargaining for state employees. If this constitutionally suspect legislation is passed, I will take legal action to protect our state from yet another case of federal overreach."

Attorney General Abbott added: "Washington needs to let Texans run Texas without the burdens of bureaucracy and union mandates."

As Attorney General Abbott's letter explains, by attempting to impose collective bargaining upon the State of Texas - and open the State up to lawsuits by labor unions in federal court if it fails to comply with the Act, the legislation violates the Tenth and Eleventh Amendments of the U.S. Constitution.

The Act's primary purpose is to force state and local governments to give collective bargaining rights to certain public employees - and the labor unions that represent them - in violation of Texas law. Currently, Texas allows local voters to seek a referendum on collective bargaining rights for police and fire department employees. The Act pending before the U.S. Senate would ignore state law and impose a federally mandated labor relations scheme upon the State of Texas.

Under Texas' Local Government Code, local police and firefighters can obtain collective bargaining rights if they follow certain statutorily mandated steps. First, they must collect signatures from the lesser of 20,000 voters or five percent of the voting public. Once that threshold is met, then the majority of local voters are given the opportunity to vote in a referendum. If a majority of the voters elect to confer collective bargaining rights on their police and firefighters, only then do labor unions have the ability to negotiate with cities and counties on their members' behalf.

There are three basic conflicts between the Act and Texas law. First, supporters claim the Act covers so-called 'public safety' employees, the legislation would actually provide collective bargaining to multiple classes of individuals who are neither police nor firefighters - such as court employees, corrections officers and probation department staffers - despite the fact those employees do not have those rights under Texas law. Second, the Act attempts to require the state to collectively bargain with certain classes of its own employees - despite the fact that state law does not grant collective bargaining rights to anyone employed by the State of Texas. Finally, while Texas law does allow local residents to confer collective bargaining rights on their police and firefighters, the Act purports to ignore petition and referendum provisions established by the Legislature.

Attorney General Abbott said: "Our quarrel is not with the brave men and women who protect and serve the public. They deserve not only court gratitude, but also legal mechanisms to help prevent parochial concerns from interfering with their official duties. But those policy decisions - such as the availability of civil service or meet-and-confer-rights - lie with the Texas Legislature, not the federal government. And no policy initiative - no matter how important or compelling - can be allowed to trample our Constitution."

Attorney General Abbott concluded: "At the heart of our state's system is not only a labor-relations framework that was properly established by the Texas Legislature - rather than the federal government - but also an appropriate respect for local control. Under Texas' approach, local taxpayers decide based on local considerations whether to give labor unions control over their relationships with local public safety officials. If that relationship is going to be changed, it must be changed at the state level by the Texas Legislature and cannot be imposed by the federal government."



Comments:

I haven't seen the Attorney General's opinion but he more be more correct than is stated here. Recently the Congressional Research Service, Congress' own research operation, issued a report on this legislation raising serious questions about whether the Constitution's Commerce Clause would be sufficient to support this usurpation of state power.

Posted by David Denholm at 7/12/2010 2:46:00 PM

Post a comment

Name/Nickname:
(required)

Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)

Comments: (plain text only)

Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
  Share   Share link on Twitter Tweet   Shared 5 times

© 1999-2014 The Police News. All rights reserved.